Overcoming Extortion Attempts by Subcontractors

Overcoming Extortion Attempts by Subcontractors

🚚 In this case study, we’re dissecting a particularly dicey situation that could happen to any logistics company: an unexpected standoff with a subcontractor over alleged additional charges. Join us as we navigate through the murky waters of contractual obligations, extortion attempts, and the power of steadfast legal positioning.

 

Client Profile 🏢

The stage is set with a forwarder, operating on a commendable scale, shipping goods from Germany to Greece. The journey, seemingly straightforward, takes an unexpected turn upon arrival due to a subcontractor’s demands.

The Challenge 🌊 

After a minor delay, the subcontractor attempts to leverage the situation by refusing to unload the truck unless an unwarranted and exorbitantly priced demurrage charge is paid upfront. This puts the forwarder in a bind, facing potential repercussions on delivery timelines and client relations.

Claims Trans Intervention 💪

Claims Trans jumps into the fray as the forwarder’s claims adjuster. Armed with expertise in the CMR Convention and a deep understanding of the legalities of transport contracts, we initiate a series of communications aimed at defusing the situation and asserting the forwarder’s rights.

Our Strategy ⚖️ 

  1. **Immediate Legal Positioning** Clearly stating the subcontractor’s obligation to unload the goods as per the contract, highlighting their attempt to detain the goods as an illegal act.
  2. **Rebuttal of Demurrage Charges** Pointing out the unreasonableness of the demanded demurrage charge and its lack of contractual basis.
  3. **Firm Stance Against Extortion** Utilizing strong language to assert the forwarder’s unwillingness to succumb to extortion, emphasizing the subcontractor’s reputational risk should they persist.

Impact & Lessons Learned 🎉 

The standoff was resolved within hours, with the subcontractor capitulating and proceeding with the unloading of goods. This episode underscores the importance of:

1. **Knowing Your Rights** Understanding the legal framework within which logistic operations occur is crucial.

2. **Standing Firm** Presenting a united and informed front against unfounded demands can deter opportunistic behavior.

3. **Preventive Measures** Incorporating clear terms regarding delays and demurrage in contracts can preempt such challenges.

Conclusion 🔍 

In the face of extortion attempts by subcontractors, knowledge and assertiveness are your best allies. This case exemplifies the power of swift, informed action underpinned by legal expertise. At Claims Trans, we’re dedicated to empowering our clients with the insights and support needed to navigate even the most challenging logistics issues.

 

Stay with us for more case studies, where we continue to unravel the complexities of the logistics world and equip you with the tools for success.

Conquering Complex Logistics Obstacles with the CMR Convention

Conquering Complex Logistics Obstacles with the CMR Convention

Introduction 🚚

In this case study we uncover the intricacies of an unexpected obstacle that required strategic thinking, effective communication, and a deep understanding of the CMR Convention. Get ready to witness the resilience and problem-solving prowess of our client as they navigate the trenches of this logistics challenge. Let’s dive in!

Client Profile 🏢

In this week’s case study, we delve into the challenges faced by a well-established transport company with a strong presence in Europe. With a wide network of clients and a reputation for handling complex logistics operations, this client finds themselves embroiled in a gripping tale that tests their problem-solving skills and understanding of the CMR Convention.

The Challenge 🌊 

One fateful day, a truck loaded with pallets arrives at its designated destination, only to encounter a daunting obstacle. The pallets, unfortunately, were poorly arranged and presented significant challenges for unloading at the warehouse. The unloading facility refuses to accept delivery, demanding that the pallets be rearranged before accepting the goods. With time slipping away and alternatives running thin, the client must grapple with finding a solution while adhering to the regulations outlined in the CMR Convention.

Claims Trans Intervention 💪

Recognizing the complexity of the situation and the need for expert guidance, the client reaches out to Claims Trans for assistance. Our team of seasoned cargo claims experts diligently assesses the circumstances, examining the details of the case against the provisions of the CMR Convention. Armed with their expertise, they become the client’s trusted legal partner, ready to navigate the trenches of this logistics challenge.

Our Strategy ⚖️ 

With the CMR Convention as their guiding principle, Claims Trans formulates a strategic approach tailored to the unique circumstances at hand. Article 15 of the Convention serves as a beacon, directing the next steps towards seeking instructions from the sender. Collaborating closely with all parties involved, our team communicates and negotiates to find a balanced and fair resolution while ensuring adherence to the legal framework.

Impact & Lessons Learned 🎉 

Through extensive dialogue and careful deliberation, a consensus emerges among the involved parties. Ultimately, the decision is made to return the truck to Spain, where the pallets can be properly rearranged. This solution aligns with the provisions of the CMR Convention while demonstrating the practical application of legal principles in real-world logistics challenges. The experience underscores the significance of clear communication, adaptability, and the expertise of claims handling professionals in overcoming obstacles and achieving successful outcomes.

Conclusion 🔍 

This case study serves as a testament to the complexity of logistics operations and the crucial role of incorporating the CMR Convention into strategic decision-making. By embracing the legal lifelines provided by the CMR Convention and partnering with trusted experts like Claims Trans, logistics companies can navigate even the most challenging circumstances with confidence and resilience.

Overcoming Contractual Challenges in International Freight Logistics

Overcoming Contractual Challenges in International Freight Logistics

Client Profile

At Claims Trans, we recently represented a small, yet resilient Bulgarian haulier company engaged in transporting goods throughout Western Europe. Their experience is emblematic of a broader trend where smaller logistics firms are often at a contractual disadvantage against larger counterparts. Our expertise in such cases was particularly relevant in 2023, handling multiple similar disputes effectively.

The Challenge

Our client entered into an exclusive agreement with a major German logistics company. However, the partnership encountered significant disruptions:

Unilateral Contract Alterations: Without our client’s consent, the German company drastically reduced the payment rates, severely affecting our client’s revenue.

Operational Hurdles: A crucial vehicle breakdown within our client’s fleet impeded their service provision.

Compounding these challenges, our client was compelled to terminate the contract. This action, however, led to punitive measures from the German firm, imposing penalties exceeding 10,000 EUR, with 6800.00 EUR attributed solely to the non-availability of the broken truck.

Our Intervention

Recognizing the injustice, Claims Trans undertook a comprehensive legal analysis. Despite our primary specialization in CMR cargo claims, our legal team is adept at offering stellar protection across various jurisdictions. In this case, we focused on the German Civil Code (BGB):

Article 275 of the BGB: We contended that the imposition of penalties for the inoperable truck was unlawful, as it was impossible for our client to fulfill these specific obligations.

Articles 313 & 314 of the BGB: The unilateral changes in payment terms warranted our client’s right to immediate contract termination, invalidating subsequent penalty claims.

Negotiation Strategy

Confronted with a large German logistics firm’s reluctance and contractual rigidity, our approach was multifaceted:

Persistent Advocacy: Twice-a-week communications to maintain pressure and visibility.

Tactical Escalation: Involving senior management and utilizing whistleblower channels to intensify scrutiny.

Unwavering Legal Stance: Repeatedly asserting our solid legal argumentation against dismissive tactics.

Settlement Adaptability: Demonstrating flexibility in negotiations to secure the best possible outcome for our client.

Impact and Lessons Learned

Our determined efforts culminated in a successful settlement, significantly reducing the penalty by over 70% and securing immediate payment release to our client, turning a potential loss into a gain of over 5000.00 EUR. Notably, even after accounting for our service fees, our client emerged with a net profit, illustrating the tangible value of expert legal intervention in such scenarios.

This case exemplifies a crucial lesson for smaller logistics companies: With specialized legal support, they can confidently challenge larger companies and protect their commercial interests. It underscores the power of informed legal strategy and relentless advocacy in leveling the playing field in international logistics.

Conclusion

This case not only fortified our client’s financial position but also set an important industry precedent. At Claims Trans, we pride ourselves on our unique blend of legal expertise in transport law and comprehensive industry understanding. Our approach goes beyond mere legal advocacy; we strive to protect and champion our clients’ commercial interests, ensuring they navigate the complexities of international logistics contracts with confidence and success regardless of the jurisdiction.

Overcoming unjustified claims: a recipe for a positive outcome

Overcoming unjustified claims: a recipe for a positive outcome

International transport is fraught with both opportunities and many challenges. Transport companies are increasingly faced with a growing number of cases and disputes that arise in the course of their work. In some cases, these disagreements reach court, where qualified expertise is crucial to achieving a positive outcome. In this article we focus on the importance of professional work in resolving disputes in the world of international transport.

 

The Facts

Our client, a carrier, was commissioned to transport goods from Bulgaria to France. At the unloading address it was found that the goods were damaged. This was also established by the entry of an appropriate remark in the CMR consignment note.

The challenges

The owner of the goods brought a claim in relation to the damaged goods directly before the court. This is generally unusual as claims for damage or shortages are brought out of court under the CMR Convention.

Our client received by post a notice from the French court before which the case was brought, of the scheduled hearing, and information about the claim. With surprise and a degree of concern, a representative of the transport company contacted us asking for assistance.

In a case such as this, great care must be taken, bearing in mind the jurisdiction of the court before which the case is pending and that the specifics of the applicable law must be taken into account.

Professional care and assistance

As experts in the field of transport law, we at Claims Trans have an extensive network of contacts of lawyers abroad with whom we work on a daily basis on various cases.

Without wasting time, we contacted our partner in France. The latter, after becoming acquainted with the case, immediately took the necessary steps to ensure that our client was properly represented in court in France.

Together with the lawyer, we discussed the main lines of defence open to us.

The claimant’s (the owner of the goods) claim was extremely high, including the cost of repairing the damaged goods, transport costs, operational loss, and legal costs.

The operating loss claimed by the plaintiff was a huge sum, which was not proven either in reason or in amount.

After a thorough discussion of the facts and the applicable law with the French lawyer, we concluded together that our client was only liable for the damage to the goods, but up to the limit of liability provided for in the CMR Convention.

As a next step, we considered that it would be best if an out-of-court settlement could be reached with the other party in order to bring the case to a swift and fair conclusion.

Our partner initiated serious negotiations with the opposing party and its legal representative, ultimately succeeding in its efforts, and the claimant agreed to be compensated up to the carrier’s limit of liability and to have the case dismissed and accordingly closed.

In the meantime, open court hearings were held and it took almost a year to reach a settlement, have it approved by the court and accordingly terminate the proceedings. Otherwise, if no agreement had been reached, perhaps the trial would have continued for another year.

Conclusions

In the end, thanks to our efforts and the professionalism of our partner, the value of the claim was reduced from nearly 90,000 EUR to 13,000 EUR. With the out-of-court settlement, the case was closed relatively quickly and entirely in the interest of our client. Justice prevailed once again and we were able to fight off the unjustified claim of the owner of the goods, which, had it been upheld by the court, could have proved disastrous for our client’s business.

 

Success in the field of transportation case management requires not only careful management, but also professional care and assistance. At Claims Trans, we provide expert claims assistance on a daily basis. Our commitment to clients and our ability to offer quick and effective solutions play a crucial role in achieving positive results that, in turn, fully satisfy our clients.

Case Unveiled: Battling Withheld Deductions of Freight Invoices

Case Unveiled: Battling Withheld Deductions of Freight Invoices

withheld deducted freights

In a riveting legal battle, Clams Trans emerged victorious by securing justice for a client facing unjustified withheld deducted freights. This milestone case sheds light on the critical role we play in advocating for our clients’ rights in the realm of logistics and transportation.

Check out our recent post and article on the topic of unpaid freights: Reclaim Your Profits: The Ultimate Solution for Recovering Unpaid Freights in the Transport Industry

The Challenge: Pursuing Resolution

When our client’s cargo suffered damages during transit from Uzbekistan to North Macedonia, a contractor unilaterally deducted a sum for damages. Armed with unclear documentation, the contractor’s actions were unjustifiable. Despite our efforts to seek an extrajudicial solution, the claimant remained unresponsive.

Legal Landscape: CMR Convention’s Significance 📜

Navigating the intricacies of international transport claims required us to lean on the CMR Convention’s tenets. Article 17, Paragraph 4, addresses exceptional risks that could limit carrier liability, while Article 18, Paragraph 2, mandates claimants to establish non-attribution to these risks.

Strategic Pursuit of Justice: Litigation in Belarus 🛤️

Undeterred by obstacles, we initiated legal proceedings in Belarus, the jurisdiction of the claimant. While challenges arose – from obstruction tactics to fabricated documents – we remained steadfast in our pursuit of justice.

Courtroom Triumph: A Defining Moment 

During a pivotal court session, the defendant presented an annex to the transport order, asserting the right to offset during trials. However, the court uncovered the consignee’s orchestrated scheme involving a forged signature – a revelation that turned the tables in our favor.

Verdict: Restitution and Beyond 👨‍⚖️

The Belarusian court’s ruling was a testament to justice prevailing. The withheld sum was ordered to be restored, accompanied by interest from the decision’s legal enforcement until payment. Armed with the court’s binding decision, we are prepared to take necessary steps, if required, to ensure our client’s rights are upheld.

Continued Progress: Enforcing Justice ⚖️

Our commitment doesn’t end with the verdict. We’ve successfully initiated the procedure for enforcing the legal decision before a Bailiff in Belarus, reinforcing our dedication to justice.

Industry Impact: A New Precedent

This triumph sets a remarkable precedent in the transportation sector. It serves as a stark reminder that substantiating claims with irrefutable evidence is paramount, and unfounded claims are unlawful – a message the court’s decision reinforces.

Championing Rights: A Collective Endeavor

While our partner’s unwavering dedication contributed significantly to this achievement, we recognize that this victory is a result of collective teamwork and expertise. This success resonates not just for our client but for all carriers and freight forwarders confronting analogous challenges.

In Conclusion: A Resounding Victory 🏁

Our victory in the courtroom echoes our dedication to championing the rights of carriers and freight forwarders globally. This triumph emboldens us to continue advocating for justice, not only within familiar jurisdictions but also in foreign courts.